Disclosure: Our content isn't financial advice. Do your due diligence and speak to your financial advisor before making any investment decision. We may earn money from products reviewed. (Learn more)
The first time I watched a contractor lose a job over insurance, there was no accident and no lawsuit. It was paperwork. A drywall sub I was helping had just landed his biggest commercial contract, and the general contractor asked for a certificate naming them as additional insured, with a waiver of subrogation, by Monday. His policy could not do it without an endorsement, his agent was out until Wednesday, and the GC gave the job to the next sub on the list. Contractor insurance is not just protection against disaster. For most trades, it is the thing that gets you through the gate.
For most small contractors: start with general liability ($1M per occurrence / $2M aggregate), add workers’ comp the day you hire, and cover your tools. NEXT is my first quote for year-round crews because certificates and additional insureds are instant and free.
Get a Contractor Quote From NEXT→Working job to job or part-time? Thimble lets you buy liability by the hour, day, or month, so you only pay when you are actually on a site.
Get Per-Job Coverage From Thimble→I run several companies of my own and spend a lot of my week advising small and mid-sized business owners across the US on the unglamorous side of growth: insurance, funding, tech infrastructure, and how they show up online. Contractors are a big share of those conversations, from one-truck handymen to electrical shops with a dozen techs. This guide is the version of the advice I give them, with real 2026 cost data and the providers I actually send them to.
Contractor insurance: the short answers
These are the four questions contractors ask me before anything else.
What kind of insurance should a contractor have?
At minimum, general liability insurance for third-party injuries and property damage. Add workers’ compensation as soon as you have employees (it is mandatory in nearly every state), commercial auto for work vehicles, and tools and equipment coverage. Many contractors also need a surety or license bond, and larger jobs often require umbrella coverage.
How much does contractor insurance cost?
Insureon’s 2026 data from 40,000+ construction customers puts general liability at about $89 a month, workers’ comp at $175, commercial auto at $268, and tools coverage at $42. Low-risk trades like painting pay far less than roofers or demolition crews, so your trade matters more than anything else.
How much does a $1 million contractor insurance policy cost?
A $1 million per-occurrence, $2 million aggregate general liability policy, the limit most contractors buy, typically runs $75 to $100 a month for lower-risk trades. NEXT reports most of its general contractor customers pay about $77 a month. High-risk work like roofing can push the same limit to several hundred dollars a month.
Who has the cheapest contractor insurance?
There is no single cheapest insurer, because each one prices certain trades aggressively and others poorly. In my experience, NEXT is hard to beat for low-to-moderate-risk trades, Thimble wins for part-time work, and biBERK is sharp on workers’ comp. The only way to find your cheapest option is to compare at least three quotes.
The coverages every contractor should understand
Most contractors I meet are underinsured in one area and overpaying in another, usually because nobody explained what each policy actually does. Here is the full menu, with average 2026 costs from Insureon’s construction cost data.
| Coverage | What it pays for | Who needs it | Avg. cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| General liability | Injuries to clients or the public, damage to their property, completed-operations claims | Every contractor; required by most clients and many licensing boards | ~$89/mo |
| Workers’ compensation | Medical bills and lost wages for injured employees | Anyone with employees; some states require it even for solo roofers | ~$175/mo |
| Commercial auto | Accidents in vehicles used for work | Anyone driving to jobs with tools or crew | ~$268/mo |
| Tools and equipment (inland marine) | Theft or damage to tools and gear at job sites or in transit | Trades with expensive, portable equipment | ~$42/mo |
| Business owner’s policy (BOP) | General liability plus property, bundled at a discount | Contractors with a shop, office, or stored inventory | ~$125/mo |
| Builder’s risk | Structures under construction and materials on site | GCs and remodelers on larger projects | ~$136/mo |
| Commercial umbrella | Extra limits above liability and auto policies | Contractors bidding commercial or municipal work | ~$93/mo |
| Surety bonds | Guarantees to clients or the state that you will finish the job and follow the rules | Licensed contractors in many states; public projects | ~$9/mo |
← Swipe sideways on mobile to see the full table.
If general liability is the one policy you are still fuzzy on, my guide to general liability insurance for small business breaks down limits, exclusions, and what a claim actually looks like. One gap I flag constantly: general liability does not cover your own tools. That is what inland marine is for, and for shop buildings or stored materials in storm-prone areas, it is worth reading up on hazard insurance for small businesses too.
What contractor insurance costs by trade
Insurers price contractors by risk class, and the spread between trades is enormous. MoneyGeek’s September 2026 analysis of general liability for one-to-four-person firms shows how wide it gets:
| Trade | Risk level | Est. general liability | What drives the price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Painting | Lower | ~$206/mo | Overspray, ladder falls, property damage |
| Handyman | Lower | ~$219/mo | Variety of tasks, in-home work |
| Carpentry | Moderate | ~$249/mo | Structural work, power tools |
| Plumbing | Moderate | ~$365/mo | Water damage claims, which get expensive fast |
| HVAC | Moderate | ~$377/mo | Gas lines, rooftop units, refrigerants |
| Electrical | Moderate to high | ~$379/mo | Fire risk and completed-operations claims |
| Roofing | High | ~$652/mo | Falls, leaks, and weather damage |
← Swipe sideways on mobile to see the full table.
Treat those as modeled estimates, not quotes. They run well above what many real buyers pay: NEXT says 93% of its general contractor customers pay about $77 a month for general liability, in a range of $56 to $227, and its tools and equipment coverage averages $32 a month. Your actual price depends on revenue, payroll, years in business, claims history, the share of work you subcontract, and your state.
The contractor insurance providers I recommend in 2026
I sort providers by who actually holds the risk, then by the type of contractor they suit. A carrier writes and pays its own claims; a broker or marketplace finds you a carrier. Neither is wrong, but you should always know which one you are dealing with.
1. NEXT Insurance (ERGO NEXT): best for most small contractors
CarrierHandymen, painters, electricians, GCsNEXT covers more than 1,300 professions and is built around exactly what contractors need on a deadline: instant, free certificates of insurance and self-serve additional insureds from the app. It is now owned by Munich Re’s ERGO Group and rated A+ (Superior) by AM Best. Watch per-project caps if you bid large jobs. My full ERGO NEXT insurance review covers the fine print.
Check NEXT’s Contractor Rates→2. Thimble: best for part-time and job-by-job work
MGA (A-rated carriers)Side-hustle trades, seasonal crewsIf you only work weekends or a few months a year, an annual policy is money left on the table. Thimble sells general liability by the hour, day, or month, with unlimited free certificates. It is a managing general agent, so the policies sit with A-rated carriers such as Markel. Read my Thimble insurance review for the refund and claims caveats.
Price a Single Job on Thimble→3. biBERK: best for workers’ comp on small crews
CarrierCrews of 2 to 15Berkshire Hathaway’s direct insurer cuts out the middleman and prices workers’ comp aggressively, all online, with A++ (Superior) rated paper behind it. Its policies are less flexible for unusual operations, but for a standard crew that needs comp fast, it belongs in your three quotes. More in my biBERK insurance review.
Get a biBERK Workers’ Comp Quote→4. Simply Business: best for comparing carriers in one pass
BrokerContractors who want several quotes fastSimply Business is a Travelers-owned broker that shows quotes from roughly 18 carriers in one form. That is useful for contractors because each carrier prices trades differently. Remember the claim goes to whichever carrier you end up with. I explain the trade-off in my Simply Business review.
Compare Contractor Quotes→5. Tivly: best for hard-to-place trades
MarketplaceRoofers, tree service, demolitionWhen online underwriting engines keep declining you, a human agent with specialty carriers is the answer. Tivly is a free matchmaking service that connects you to a licensed agent from a network of hundreds of carriers. It does not issue policies itself; see my Tivly review for how the hand-off works.
Get Matched With an Agent→6. The Hartford: best for established contractors with 5+ employees
CarrierGrowing shops with fleets and payrollOnce you have a shop, several vehicles, and a real payroll, a full carrier that bundles a BOP, workers’ comp, and auto starts to beat the digital players. The Hartford has done this since 1810, though only some lines quote fully online. Details in my Hartford business insurance review.
Get a Hartford Quote→One name you will notice is missing: Hiscox. It is excellent for consultants and professional services, but it is not built for trades. For the wider field beyond contractors, my ranking of the top business insurance companies in America compares all of them side by side.
State rules that decide what you must carry
Licensing boards, not insurers, often set your minimums. Before you buy, check your state’s contractor board, because a policy that is fine for clients can still fall short of a license requirement. A few examples I run into most:
| State | What contractors typically need |
|---|---|
| California | A $25,000 contractor bond for licensed contractors; LLC licensees must carry at least $1 million in liability insurance (more with over five personnel) plus a $100,000 employee/worker bond, per the CSLB’s LLC requirements. Roofers must carry workers’ comp even without employees. |
| Florida | Certified general contractors must show general liability of at least $300,000 bodily injury and $50,000 property damage, and construction businesses need workers’ comp with even one employee. |
| Texas | No statewide general contractor license or insurance mandate, but licensed trades (electricians, plumbers, HVAC) have their own rules, and nearly every client contract demands general liability anyway. |
| Everywhere else | Requirements vary by state, city, and trade. Check your licensing board, then check your contracts, which are usually stricter than the law. |
← Swipe sideways on mobile to see the full table.
Florida contractors in particular should also compare local options; my roundup of Florida’s best business insurance firms covers carriers that write in hurricane country. On the federal side, the SBA’s business insurance guide is a good primer on which policies are legally required once you have employees.
Carrier, broker, or marketplace: know who you are buying from
This is the point I repeat in almost every client call. A lot of the “contractor insurance companies” you see advertised are not insurance companies at all. Look into the back end and you find a broker or a lead-generation site that places your policy with a carrier you have never heard of. That is not automatically bad: a good broker can find a roofer coverage that no online carrier will write. But it changes three things:
- Who pays your claim. Always the carrier, never the broker or marketplace.
- Who you call at renewal. Brokers can re-shop you; carriers just re-price you.
- Whose financial strength matters. Check the AM Best rating of the carrier named on your declarations page, not the brand on the website.
The second rule I give contractors: match the insurer to your type of work. A painter and an excavation company should almost never end up with the same carrier. One has ladder falls and overspray; the other has heavy equipment, trenching, and subcontractors. Insurers that love one of those risks often price the other one out of the market.
How I would shop it: the three-quote rule for contractors
I never let a client buy on the first quote, and I do not buy that way for my own companies either. Here is the process I walk contractors through:
- List your contract requirements first. Pull your three biggest client contracts and note the limits, additional insured language, waiver of subrogation, and primary and non-contributory wording they demand.
- Get one direct carrier quote, one broker quote, and one specialist. For a typical crew, that might be NEXT, Simply Business, and biBERK for comp. For a high-risk trade, swap one in for Tivly.
- Compare exclusions, not just price. Look for per-project limits, residential or height exclusions, and whether completed operations are covered.
- Ask about the audit. Find out how the carrier treats 1099 subs and collect certificates from every sub you hire.
- Diarize your renewal. Re-shop 45 days before it renews. Renewal creep is where contractors quietly overpay.
Insurance is also a cash-flow line, and I see contractors stretch themselves buying trucks and equipment at the same time their premiums jump. If you are financing gear, my comparison of installment vs. revolving small business loans explains which structure fits lumpy contractor income.
Mistakes I see contractors make
- Hiring uninsured subs. A remodeler I advise got a five-figure workers’ comp audit bill because three of his subs had no coverage of their own. Collect a certificate before anyone touches a tool.
- Using a personal auto policy for the work truck. Personal policies routinely deny claims when the vehicle is used for business.
- Assuming general liability covers bad workmanship. It covers the damage your work causes, not the cost of redoing the work itself.
- Buying the cheapest limit. $500,000 policies save little and disqualify you from most commercial jobs, which usually require $1 million per occurrence and $2 million aggregate.
- Letting the policy lapse between jobs. Completed-operations claims can arrive years later; a gap can leave you uncovered for work you already finished.
For most contractors, the fastest path is a NEXT quote for year-round coverage or a Thimble policy for job-by-job work. Both take minutes, issue certificates instantly, and let you compare before you commit.
Start My NEXT Quote→ Start My Thimble Quote→Contractor insurance: frequently asked questions
Do I need insurance as a 1099 subcontractor?
In practice, yes. Most general contractors require subs to carry their own general liability, usually $1 million per occurrence, and to name the GC as additional insured. Without it, you either lose the job or the GC’s insurer charges them for your payroll at audit, which they will pass back to you.
Does contractor general liability insurance cover my tools?
No. General liability covers injuries and damage you cause to other people and their property. Your own tools and equipment need a separate tools and equipment (inland marine) policy, which averages about $32 to $42 a month for most small contractors.
Does contractor insurance cover faulty workmanship?
Generally not. General liability pays for property damage or injuries your work causes, such as a leak that ruins a client’s floor, but not the cost of fixing or redoing your own defective work. Warranty and workmanship issues are a business risk you manage through contracts and quality control.
Do I need workers’ compensation if I have no employees?
Usually not as a sole owner, but there are exceptions. Some states, such as California for roofers, require it regardless, and many GCs will not let you on site without either a policy or a certificate of exemption. Once you hire your first employee, workers’ comp becomes mandatory in nearly every state.
What is the difference between a contractor bond and insurance?
Insurance protects you, paying claims when you cause damage or injury. A surety or license bond protects your client or the state; if the bond pays out because you failed to finish a job or follow the rules, you must repay the surety. Many states require both for licensed contractors.
Can I get contractor insurance for a single job?
Yes. Short-term general liability is sold by the hour, day, or month through providers such as Thimble, which suits part-time contractors and anyone who needs a certificate of insurance for one specific project. If you work most weeks of the year, an annual policy is usually cheaper.
How fast can a contractor get a certificate of insurance?
With digital carriers, often in minutes. NEXT and Thimble both issue certificates instantly online or in their apps and let you add additional insureds yourself for free, while traditional agents may take one to three business days, longer if an endorsement is required.
My bottom line
Contractor insurance is a qualification as much as a safety net: the right policy gets you onto bigger jobs, and the wrong one costs you work before anything ever goes wrong. Start with general liability at $1 million / $2 million, add workers’ comp the moment you hire, cover your tools, and check your state board’s minimums. Then follow the three-quote rule, and make sure you know whether you are talking to a carrier or a broker. Do that, and you will be covered properly at a price that makes sense for your trade.
Amine Rahal is an entrepreneur and investor. He is passionate about alternative investments, Bitcoin, precious metals and startups. He enjoys covering US politics, retirement investing, alternative investing and geopolitics.
