Fisher Precious Metals Review: Understanding the Investor Experience

Disclosure: Our content isn't financial advice. Do your due diligence and speak to your financial advisor before making any investment decision. We may earn money from products reviewed. (Learn more)

Fisher Precious Metals is one of the more genuinely distinctive companies in the precious metals IRA space — not because of its size, but because of how it operates. John and Lynn Fisher founded the company in 2007 and still run it. Both are precious metals IRA owners themselves, not just dealers who sell the product. Clients can call and speak directly with the founders. The custodian is named publicly. All three depositories are named publicly. The company was named USA Bullion Dealer of the Year. That combination of founder-level access, named partners, and a clean 18-year record is harder to find than most investors expect.

The one catch is real and affects some investors more than others: no online ordering. All purchases are placed by phone. The website has a downloadable price sheet but no live pricing. If you want to browse, compare premiums, and buy without talking to anyone, Fisher Precious Metals is not the right company. If you are comfortable with a relationship-driven, phone-first model and value direct access to the founders, the experience is genuinely different from what larger, more automated operations offer.

Fisher Precious Metals at a Glance

Not many dealers mention their custodian along with their depositories, but very few list all of their storage facilities. Fisher Precious Metals mentions all of them – the custodian is called New Direction IRA, and depositories are IDS of Delaware, IDS of Canada, and Strategic Wealth Preservation in the Cayman Islands. This much transparency is better than what the majority of companies provide here and does not require much pre-purchase due diligence from the client.

The most interesting point about Fisher Precious Metals’ offering is the ability to talk directly to their owners. The company was established by John and Lynn Fisher and they still own and manage it. So, if you make a call, you get connected with people who are actively involved in precious metals IRAs since before the crisis of 2008 and have such IRAs themselves. It is quite different from talking to a commission-based salesperson in a large corporation.

A lack of an option to order precious metals via the web is the greatest drawback of this company’s services. They do not allow online orders anymore and only provide a downloadable price list. So, there is no spot plus premium price on the website, and people who want to check their premiums before ordering can do it manually.

Pros & Cons

Company Background

The firm was established by John and Lynn Fisher in 2007 in Deerfield Beach, Florida. Together, the founders had been involved in precious metal investments for more than two decades at the time. The philosophy upon which the firm was founded is evident in its publications: clients are entitled to dealing with those who own the very investment they seek. In other words, both John and Lynn Fisher themselves have precious metals IRAs. This feature sets them apart from the majority of dealers in the field, who sell more actively than invest personally.

The firm has received several awards, among which stands out USA Bullion Dealer of the Year. The company works from just one location in Florida but deals across all of the United States. The firm’s Information Center, available on its website, is among the best in terms of content, which includes FAQs, market charts, analysts’ comments, articles, and video content. Furthermore, the firm offers a helpful and informative guide “Avoiding Bullion Counterfeits”. It is far more relevant and valuable than typical IRA rollover guides offered by competitors.

For a broader view of the precious metals IRA competitive landscape, see our precious metals IRA reviews page.

Management Team

President & Co-founder — John Fisher

John Fisher serves as President and co-founded the company with his wife Lynn in 2007. He is listed as the principal contact in BBB filings. He has over two decades of experience in precious metals investing and holds a precious metals IRA personally. Clients can reach him directly by phone.

Co-founder — Lynn Fisher

Lynn Fisher co-founded the company alongside John. She contributes to the company’s educational mission and client advisory work. Both founders remain active in day-to-day operations, which is the basis of Fisher’s direct-owner-access model.

IRA Custodian and Storage

Custodian: New Direction IRA

Fisher Precious Metals uses the services of New Direction IRA as its IRA custodian. New Direction IRA is a reputable IRA administrator providing services to investors who invest in alternative assets such as precious metals, real estate, and private equity. The IRA custodian takes care of maintaining the account and ensuring that it complies with the requirements of the Internal Revenue Service.

Storage: Three Named Partners

Three depository options are available, covering different geographic preferences:

• International Depository Services of Delaware (IDS) — domestic U.S. storage, Wilmington, Delaware
• International Depository Services of Canada (IDS) — Canadian storage option
• Strategic Wealth Preservation (SWP) — international storage, George Town, Grand Cayman

All three are established and credible vault operators used by multiple dealers across the industry. The availability of Canadian and Cayman Islands storage is useful for investors who want geographic diversification of their physical holdings. For context on how storage location decisions work, see our articles on gold storage vaults.

Products Available

Fisher Precious Metals offers gold, silver, platinum, and palladium both as IRA-qualifying coins and as collectibles. They deal with products sourced from prestigious mints like the United States Mint, Perth Mint, and Royal Canadian Mint. Their stock also includes fine jewelry and diamonds for customers who want to trade these items. All orders are done through telephonic communication, since their online catalog serves the sole purpose of providing product information.

IRA-Eligible Gold Products (Examples)

• Gold American Eagle
• Gold American Buffalo
• Gold Canadian Maple Leaf
• Gold Austrian Philharmonic
• Gold Australian Kangaroo

IRA-Eligible Silver Products (Examples)

• Silver American Eagle
• Silver Canadian Maple Leaf
• Silver Austrian Philharmonic
• Silver Australian Kangaroo
• Silver Britannia

IRA-Eligible Platinum Products (Examples)

• Platinum American Eagle
• Platinum Canadian Maple Leaf
• Austrian Platinum Philharmonic
• Australian Platinum Koala

IRA-Eligible Palladium Products

• Palladium Canadian Maple Leaf

Additional Products

• Pre-1933 gold collectible coins
• Certified and rare collectible coins
• Fine jewelry and diamonds

For guidance on how metals selection fits into a retirement portfolio, see our guide to precious metals investing.

Who Fisher Precious Metals Is Best Suited For

Worth a Closer Look If You Are:

• An investor who wants to speak directly with the owners, not a sales rep, and values that kind of direct advisory access
• Someone for whom knowing the custodian and all three depositories before calling is important — Fisher names them all publicly
• A retirement investor who appreciates that the founders own the same type of IRA they are recommending
• Someone interested in international or Canadian storage alongside the standard U.S. option
• An investor who values founder-level knowledge and a boutique, relationship-first service model over a larger automated operation

Consider Alternatives If You Are:

• Looking for online ordering or a self-serve digital purchase experience — Fisher is phone-only
• Wanting live pricing displayed on the website before making contact
• Expecting clearly published annual fee schedules upfront
• Someone who needs high review volume on major platforms to feel confident
• An investor starting with a very small balance where a boutique firm’s higher per-interaction cost makes less sense

For a full competitive comparison, see our precious metals IRA reviews page. For the bigger picture on why gold belongs in a retirement portfolio, see our articles on inflation risk and inflation hedges.

Fisher Precious Metals vs Other Gold IRA Companies

Fisher Precious Metals competes in a boutique tier defined by founder access and relationship depth rather than scale or digital features. Here is how it stacks up against key peers:

Noble Gold Investments is our #1 pick for 2026. Noble Gold names its custodians and depositories, publishes its fees, and assigns a dedicated IRA specialist per account. For transparency combined with guided specialist support, it is the standard against which others are compared.

Augusta Precious Metals is the right comparison for investors who want the most education-intensive, premium IRA setup in the category. Augusta goes deeper on pre-commitment education than Fisher, particularly for larger rollovers.

Goldline competes on brand recognition and a longer national advertising footprint. Fisher trades brand scale for direct owner access — a different model for a different type of investor.

USAGOLD is the closest philosophical peer to Fisher among the options covered here. Both are smaller, relationship-driven dealers focused on physical bullion education and long-term ownership. Worth comparing directly if Fisher is on your list.

GoldCore for investors whose primary interest is international custody infrastructure. Fisher offers offshore storage through SWP but GoldCore positions international custody as its central value proposition.

Advantage Gold for rollover-focused investors who want a more structured, guided IRA process with higher online transparency than Fisher’s phone-first model offers.

Best gold investment companies covers the full field for investors running a wider comparison.

Fisher’s strongest differentiators are founder access, named partners, and a clean 18-year record. The phone-only ordering model and thin digital presence are the areas where larger competitors have a clear edge.

Final Verdict

Fisher Precious Metals is a legitimate, founder-operated precious metals company with real differentiators. Eighteen years in business, a clean complaint record, named custodian, named depositories, direct owner access, and the institutional credibility of a USA Bullion Dealer of the Year award. For investors who want to speak with the people who built the company and have personal stakes in the same type of investment, Fisher is one of a small number of options that actually delivers that.

The phone-only ordering model and absence of live website pricing will frustrate investors who want to research and transact digitally. That is not a minor inconvenience for some buyers. It is a dealbreaker. Know which camp you are in before you call.

If Fisher Precious Metals appeals based on its founder-access model and full partner transparency, pursue the conversation. Get the New Direction IRA custodian fee in writing, confirm storage costs at your preferred depository, and compare the product premiums against Noble Gold Investments and at least one other provider before committing retirement funds.

Fisher Precious Metals

Fisher Precious Metals - byMohammed Saqib,April 1, 2011

4/ 5stars

on

Fisher Precious Metals

• Phone : (800) 390-8576
• URL :
  https://fisherpreciousmetals.com/
  

• Global Rating
• Our Global Rating (GR) is Math-Based. (Learn how it works)
  (4/5)
• Very Good

• User Rating

• (0/5)
• 0 No reviews yet!

Leave your rating

Review Summary :

Founded in 2007, Fisher Precious Metals is family-operated and headquartered in Deerfield Beach, Florida. This gold IRA company and precious metals dealer offers a good selection of both IRA-eligible products and collectible coins. Clients can choose from International Depository Services of Delaware, International Depository Services of Canada, and Strategic Wealth Preservation for secure storage options. The company has a dedicated precious metals IRA website providing all pertinent information on this type of retirement account. Fisher Precious Metals does not have product pricing on the website - however, a “pricing” button is available to download the inventory price sheet. Furthermore, the company no longer offers online ordering - instead, customers must now call Fisher directly to place all orders.

 

Get Info Kit Now

Have you purchased products from Fisher Precious Metals? Leave a review!

Leave your rating

Field is Required

Field is Required

Field is Required

Field is Required

Leave a rating: