by | Feb 4, 2025 | Business, Insurance

Last Updated: February 5, 2025

Disclosure: Our content isn't financial advice. Do your due diligence and speak to your financial advisor before making any investment decision. We may earn money from products reviewed. (Learn more)

The state of Indiana produced $404.3 billion worth of goods in 2023. These figures show that the state is undergoing a period of economic growth. You may be surprised to know Indiana produces more steel than any other state and is a leading automobile producer

Businesses should have reliable insurance coverage, especially when they are operating in a vibrant economy as Indiana. For this, business owners have to get in touch with a reliable provider that can help you get coverage that protects your investment from unexpected financial loss. 

Today, we will be looking at nine prominent business insurance providers in Indiana along with their products and clients.

Tivly

Tivly is an insurance marketplace through which customers gain access to insurance coverage from more than 200 reputable providers in the state of Indiana. 

It provides basic plans like liability protection, and worker’s compensation as well as other insurance types across the state. Businesses associated with various niches like professional services, healthcare or construction employees can acquire affordable policies without any hassles. 

Tivly stands out for their customer-first approach in their operations.

NEXT Insurance

NEXT Insurance provides insurance solutions for businesses with multiple needs across Indiana. Their products include general liability insurance along with workers’ compensation, commercial property and cyber policies.

NEXT Insurance helps different business sectors such as retail, technology, and healthcare obtain necessary insurance protections that protect them against operational disruptions.

InsuranceBee

InsuranceBee is one of the leading insurance firms in  Indiana, providing cutting-edge solutions to businesses working in retail, technology, and medical services sectors.

InsuranceBee stands out from the rest by letting customers purchase coverage only for a certain projects. They have a digital platform through which clients can acquire coverage fast and cheap.

Thimble

Thimble is a top-tier insurance agency that supports construction workers and small businesses across Indiana with their insurance needs. Their portfolio consists of basic protection plans for liability claims along with business owner’s policies and cyber insurance. 

The industries they serve include event management, cleaning and construction industries. The client can just log on to their online portal and buy coverage without an inconvenience.

Hiscox

Hiscox delivers insurance protection to small or mid-sized companies in the state of Indiana. They usually deal in general liability, professional liability and business owner’s policies. Their personalized protection helps clients stay on top of their game. 

Hiscox offers insurance solutions to companies in technology marketing and consulting sectors. Many businesses in Indiana choose Hiscox because of its prices and quick claim settlement process.

Hylant Group

Hylant Group is a prominent insurance brokerage company that operates across Indiana and enjoys a success rate. Their business provides multiple types of insurance with general liability protection with workers’ comp and cyber insurance being some of them. 

As part of their services, Hylant Group helps their clients manage business risks and advises them on employee benefits. The company has proved its mettle by helping its Indiana clients with their high-quality service.

Liberty Mutual Insurance

Liberty Mutual stands as an established insurance provider who has served comprehensive business solutions to Indiana business for many years. 

They offer various insurance protection types including general and professional liability insurance for clients that are operating in construction and manufacturing sectors. 

They also help healthcare providers with workers compensation insurance coverage alongside commercial vehicle insurance. 

Brown & Brown Insurance

Brown & Brown Insurance ranks highly as an insurance agency that successfully serves customers throughout Indiana. The insurance company offers different types of insurance both for personal and business use. People praise the company for its quality services and dedication to its customers.

American United Life Insurance Company

The American United Life Insurance Company is part of OneAmerica Financial. The insurance firm has been offering life insurance and retirement plans along with employee benefits services to customers across Indiana. 

The company delivers their services to clients through their distribution networks like Securian Financial and AmeriLife. AUL maintains a solid financial status and provides top quality services to Indiana-based setups.

Brief Overview Of Indiana’s Leading Insurance Companies

The following chart presents a clear picture at the nine top businesses including their services and features that earned their status in India’s thriving business landscape.

Insurance ProviderCoverage OptionsUnique Selling Points
ThimbleGeneral liability, professional liability, workers’ compensationProject-based policies, quick quotes, minimal paperwork
NEXT InsuranceGeneral liability, workers’ compensation, commercial auto, propertyFast quotes, easy online management, budget-friendly plans
HiscoxGeneral liability, professional liability, business owner’s policiesCustomizable plans, competitive rates, fast claims process
InsuranceBeeGeneral liability, workers’ compensation, cyber insurance, commercial propertyEasy comparison tool, affordable rates, wide provider network
TivlyGeneral liability, professional liability, workers’ compensation, commercial propertyWide provider network, efficient matching, affordable plans
Brown & Brown InsuranceAuto, home, commercial, farm insuranceIndependent agency, diverse coverage plans
American United Life InsuranceLife insurance, annuities, retirement planning, employee benefitsOver 140 years of experience, retirement and benefit solutions
Hylant GroupGeneral liability, workers’ compensation, business interruptionPersonalized risk management, employee benefits consulting
Liberty MutualGeneral liability, professional liability, workers’ compensation, commercial autoGlobal presence, customizable policies, strong claims management support

Top Cities In Indiana For Business Insurance

Indiana has attracted businesses from all over the United States to start their operations here owing to its thriving business landscape. High-rated insurance companies offer coverage to businesses throughout Indiana cities they can grow. Here, you will find the hotspots for business insurance in Indiana

  1. Indianapolis
  2. Fort Wayne
  3. Evansville
  4. South Bend
  5. Carmel
  6. Fishers
  7. Lafayette
  8. Bloomington
  9. Muncie
  10. Noblesville

Indiana Government Resources for Business Insurance

Check out these government resources about business insurance for the state of Indiana:

Conclusion

Having a proper business insurance provider is key in protecting your business in case of any unforeseen events. The nine companies boast a variety of coverage plans for your Indiana business. 

If you are planning to expand your business outside the state, you can read about the trusted business insurance firms in Arkansas and Georgia. For additional funding options, you can also check out our listings of Indiana’s leading business loans and startup financial firms For expert analysis and insights, visit Sophisticated Investor and find the best insurance for your company’s insurance needs.

Brandi Marcene

Brandi is a financial writer and entrepreneur with decades of expertise covering U.S. business and financial topics. Her work has been featured on Consumer Affairs, ASBN Small Business Network, Koho and many other top financial publications.